Question:
running & 120 mg of prozac every day will keep the blues away http://community.webtv.net/ultrajohn1/dummyup http://community.webtv.net/ultrajohn1/talkischeapliesr http://community.webtv.net/ultrajohn1/splat http://community.webtv.net/ultrajohn1/hiitssarahtime http://community.webtv.net/ultrajohn1/Iwasborntorun http://community.webtv.net/ultrajohn1/welcum
Response:
[[ This message was both posted and mailed: see the "To," "Cc," and "Newsgroups" headers for details. ]] – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thanks John and everyone else who was kind enough to post their experiences of running and depression/anxiety. It helps in so many ways to know that there are others who are using running as a treatment or adjunct treatment to these oh so human of conditions I see that a number of people have presented anecdotal evidence of the benefits of exercise (specifically running) in the treatment of depression. As a grad student I worked on a number of projects which examined this very topic. The prof I was working with had recently published a meta-analysis that suggests that exercise is as effective in treating clinical depression as psychotherapy or psychopharmacology. Exercise combined with psychotherapy was found to be the most effective treatment. The meta also found that exercise was effective at treating all times of depression (mild, moderate, and severe) and the greatest reductions were seen in those that were the most depressed at baseline (which is logical). I saw another study (not sure if it is published yet), that compared exercise to Zoloft and found that Zoloft was more effective at reducing depression at 4 weeks, exercise and Zoloft were equal at 8 weeks, and exercise was more effective at 12 weeks. — Jeremy Pomeroy http://www.home.earthlink.net/~azmtbr/ http://clubs.yahoo.com/clubs/teamadventureracing "mens sana in corpore sano"
Jeremy, Would you cite the location of the meta-analysis on exercise as a treatment for cliical depression. Many thanks, Ozzie Gontang
Response:
Mike, Around the beginning of June I had an anxiety attack ( after the last few years of too much beer and too many smokes). The doctors gave me Valium, Xanax and tried to put me on Zoloft. Not being inclined to solve problems with drugs , I joined a local running club. I refused the drugs ( except a week or two of valium) and turned things around. I finished my first marathon ( ok..it was 5 hours) and have signed up for a local Triathlon in April ( St anthony’s). Chemical imbalances are a major cause of most anxiety/depression related illness and these CAN be altered with diet/exercise. I firmly believe that Dr,’s spend WAY to much time prescribing and not enough time trying to change the diet and excercise patterns of their patients. Here is a Cut and Paste from WebMD on anxiety: "Healthy Lifestyle A healthy lifestyle that includes exercise, adequate rest, and good nutrition can help to reduce the impact of anxiety attacks. Rhythmic aerobic and yoga exercise programs lasting for more than 15 weeks have been found to help reduce anxiety. Strength, or resistance training does not seem to help anxiety." John – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.? Thanks, Mike
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Mike, Around the beginning of June I had an anxiety attack ( after the last few years of too much beer and too many smokes). The doctors gave me Valium, Xanax and tried to put me on Zoloft. Not being inclined to solve problems with drugs , I joined a local running club. I refused the drugs ( except a week or two of valium) and turned things around. I finished my first marathon ( ok..it was 5 hours) and have signed up for a local Triathlon in April ( St anthony’s). Chemical imbalances are a major cause of most anxiety/depression related illness and these CAN be altered with diet/exercise. I firmly believe that Dr,’s spend WAY to much time prescribing and not enough time trying to change the diet and excercise patterns of their patients. Here is a Cut and Paste from WebMD on anxiety: "Healthy Lifestyle A healthy lifestyle that includes exercise, adequate rest, and good nutrition can help to reduce the impact of anxiety attacks. Rhythmic aerobic and yoga exercise programs lasting for more than 15 weeks have been found to help reduce anxiety. Strength, or resistance training does not seem to help anxiety." John I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.? Thanks, Mike
Thanks John and everyone else who was kind enough to post their experiences of running and depression/anxiety. It helps in so many ways to know that there are others who are using running as a treatment or adjunct treatment to these oh so human of conditions
Response:
My situation is similar to Cam’s. After a very tough, messy beakup with my live-in girlfriend of five years, I moped horribly for an entire year, became clinically depressed, and then decided to dig myself out of the hole. I quit smoking and started running the next day. I have never looked back since.
oh c’mon, David… I’ll bet you HAVE looked back, like at that guy in second place when you won that race recently! :) it’s too bad that many of us must hit (nearly) rock bottom before making a major *positive* life change. but i guess this is what makes life interesting. Cam
Response:
My wife wrote her MS thesis on excercise and depression, so we (uh, she) have read quite a bit on the subject. Therefore, we have a pretty extensive reference section should someone be interested. There is quatifiable evidence that exercise helps to a certain point, however there can be tendency for higher level athletes to potentially suffer from more symptoms of depression in certain situations. Well, that last statement is an oversimplification, but I don’t want to bore anyone.
Response:
We dont need any more people who are excited about life. Thanks anyway.
Response:
Thanks John and everyone else who was kind enough to post their experiences of running and depression/anxiety. It helps in so many ways to know that there are others who are using running as a treatment or adjunct treatment to these oh so human of conditions
I see that a number of people have presented anecdotal evidence of the benefits of exercise (specifically running) in the treatment of depression. As a grad student I worked on a number of projects which examined this very topic. The prof I was working with had recently published a meta-analysis that suggests that exercise is as effective in treating clinical depression as psychotherapy or psychopharmacology. Exercise combined with psychotherapy was found to be the most effective treatment. The meta also found that exercise was effective at treating all times of depression (mild, moderate, and severe) and the greatest reductions were seen in those that were the most depressed at baseline (which is logical). I saw another study (not sure if it is published yet), that compared exercise to Zoloft and found that Zoloft was more effective at reducing depression at 4 weeks, exercise and Zoloft were equal at 8 weeks, and exercise was more effective at 12 weeks. — Jeremy Pomeroy http://www.home.earthlink.net/~azmtbr/ http://clubs.yahoo.com/clubs/teamadventureracing "mens sana in corpore sano"
Response:
in the movie ’storm and sorrow’ a climber after seeing 3 teams of climbing die one way or another, states "i can always go back to climbing" I feel that way when it just hits the fan . A fortress of solitude (not loneliness mind you) my asics aford me as i propel down the road. plodzilla – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.? Thanks, Mike
Response:
I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.?
I can’t speak about depression but I did run for stress control and it was VERY effective. I was always a morning runner and go to work feeling very calm and the usual anxiety driven demands seemed less daunting. I could not begin to guess how much it would help general depression but I’ll bet it does little harm. — Caveat Lector "the further you go outside, the further you go inside" – B. McKibben Doug Freese
Response:
I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life.
Agreed! Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.?
While running has always been part of my life, the amount and frequency have varied, and usually related to how I’ve felt. During times of high stress (working on my dissertation for instance) I was running 8 miles every other day, now I’m down to 3 miles 3 or 4 times a week, but that’s changing once again. Running for me is my main antidode to feeling sad/depressed or stressed. It’s hard not to feel better after a run. Esmail — 32N 83W http://www.cs.mercer.edu/bonak
Response:
My situation is similar to Cam’s. After a very tough, messy beakup with my live-in girlfriend of five years, I moped horribly for an entire year, became clinically depressed, and then decided to dig myself out of the hole. I quit smoking and started running the next day. I have never looked back since. — David (in Hamilton, Ont) "You never conquer a mountain. You stand on the summit a few moments; and then the wind blows your footprints away." Arlene Blum, Annapurna http://www.angelfire.com/nc/swstudio/home.html – – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.? Thanks, Mike Yes, Mike…. running has got to be the best medication for low to moderate depression. I think that some people may need the medication if they have extreme depression, but I know from experience that running can lift a person (who likes this activity, of course) out of the doldrums. Five years ago, I began to go through the first stages of a marital separation. Not a good time. I was not a terribly active person at the time, but I recognized the fact that I needed a healthy outlet. I tried out kung fu, tai chi, some weights, and even though these made me feel great for a while, my interest in each of them waned. When I stumbled upon running, it was a godsend. A daily dose of the great outdoors, fresh air, exercise – all leading to racing and training. I’d say that if you enjoy running – for whatever reason – do it, and you will feel better. But if it becomes obsessive to the point of overtraining, or if it interferes with other aspects of your life, then it would be time to reassess why you are doing it. Best of luck, Cam
Response:
I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.? Thanks, Mike
Yes, Mike…. running has got to be the best medication for low to moderate depression. I think that some people may need the medication if they have extreme depression, but I know from experience that running can lift a person (who likes this activity, of course) out of the doldrums. Five years ago, I began to go through the first stages of a marital separation. Not a good time. I was not a terribly active person at the time, but I recognized the fact that I needed a healthy outlet. I tried out kung fu, tai chi, some weights, and even though these made me feel great for a while, my interest in each of them waned. When I stumbled upon running, it was a godsend. A daily dose of the great outdoors, fresh air, exercise – all leading to racing and training. I’d say that if you enjoy running – for whatever reason – do it, and you will feel better. But if it becomes obsessive to the point of overtraining, or if it interferes with other aspects of your life, then it would be time to reassess why you are doing it. Best of luck, Cam
Response:
You just have to look at an injured runner, you will see mood change and the feeling that something is missing. Even if croos-training is involve+ADs- it is not the same high as only running can provide. When you have been a runner for 20 years, this habit of mood elevation is a must. Dan Mike a +AOk-crit dans le message … +AD4-I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am +AD4-hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. +AD4-Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. +AD4- +AD4-Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for +AD4-depression/anxiety.? +AD4-Thanks, +AD4- +AD4-Mike
Response:
I’ve been a runner since 1978. I recall vaguely a study, probably 15 to 20 years ago, in which a group of patients with depression etc were separated into 2 groups. One group received traditional psychiatric therapy, the other group was put on a running program. At the conclusion of the test each group was evaluated for progress. The evaluator could detect no significant differences between the groups. The running group improved at the same rate as the therapy group. I’m not surprised. I believe strongly that running helped me to maintain my sanity during a divorce. It’s hard to feel bad after a good run. Michael
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – You just have to look at an injured runner, you will see mood change and the feeling that something is missing. Even if croos-training is involve+ADs- it is not the same high as only running can provide. When you have been a runner for 20 years, this habit of mood elevation is a must. Dan Mike a +AOk-crit dans le message … +AD4-I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am +AD4-hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. +AD4-Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. +AD4- +AD4-Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for +AD4-depression/anxiety.? +AD4-Thanks, +AD4- +AD4-Mike
Response:
I find that running is very helpful for depression/anxiety and am hoping that I can eventually substitute running for medication. Generally I feel hardier, energetic, and more excited about life. Does anyone have experience or generally thoughts about running for depression/anxiety.? Thanks, Mike
Response: