Question:
Hi, this is my first posting to this group. I was steered to this group by some very nice folks on the alt.support.asthma group. I am 47. When I take HRT (low dose BC pills, FemHrt or Estratest) I have full blown asthma attacks. (I’ve had night sweats, insomnia, can’t think straight, erratic periods or none at all and, for about the last year, no sex drive whatsoever!) Recently I’ve been really miserable and housebound from asthma. I’m off all the hormone pills, have been trying black cohosh and progesterone cream for 4 months now and it seems to have helped lessen the number of days I have the night sweats before my periods. I was eating a soy food bar each day, as well, but stopped that recently as I’m also trying to eliminate foods to see if anything is also aggravating asthma. Once I get through this attack, my OB/GYN wants me to try topical USP progesterone cream applied topically for low libido. I’m worried about trying it, though. Has anyone else experienced these problems? There are times my asthma flares and I cannot think of any reason other than major hormonal shifts in my body due just to menopause, never mind the HRT. My asthma doc says he knows that hormones can play a part in asthma but my OB/GYN has never heard of this. Thank heavens, he is a very nice, patient man and worked with me. Thanks for any help you can give. Sometimes feel like I’m losing my mind with all this going on….. Thanks for listening. Lynn
Response:
Lynn <hlang…@home.com
wrote: Hi, this is my first posting to this group.
Welcome to the group and to the fun process of peri…. No doubt someone with more specific info will be along in a minute (or maybe even before my message appears) to help you, but I’ll do for starters. Or p’raps you could start delving into the Land o’Links: <http://menopause.tripod.com
for yourself. I am 47. When I take HRT (low dose BC pills, FemHrt or Estratest) I have full blown asthma attacks.
Hmmmmm…. I found that going onto the Pill all those years ago actually improved my asthma (because whenever I was even a day later than the regulation 28 days, I’d start having horrendous cramps which seemed to trigger an attack, or maybe it was the hormone surge, or maybe it was just my bad mood, or maybe…). But when I was reading a.s.a, I got the impression from other people’s stories that any change in hormones in any direction can cause a change in asthma in any direction, so I could well believe that someone else can have problems. I wonder if you’re actually allergic to those versions of the Pill? I don’t mean allergic to the active ingredients, but to the allegedly inert padders that are added to make the Pill large enough for you to pick up and swallow? After all, there are some asthmatics who report they have problems with the new environmentally-friendly propellents used in inhalers. You could try asking your doctor to check what else is in those Pills, if you really want to continue trying them (I did my homework and decided to stop, but your situation seems different from mine–my asthma has improved recently).
(I’ve had night sweats, insomnia, can’t think straight, erratic periods or none at all and, for about the last year, no sex drive whatsoever!)
Yup. Sounds like you’ve come to the right place! (I’m experiencing a new variation at the moment–insomnia combined with jet-lag. This is not recommendable. Note that the rambling nature of this message can be blamed on the fact that it’s 2:40 AM and I did not manage to sleep significantly last night, but I’m still wide-awake. Drat it.)
Recently I’ve been really miserable and housebound from asthma.
How dismal.
I’m off all the hormone pills, have been trying black cohosh and progesterone cream for 4 months now and it seems to have helped lessen the number of days I have the night sweats before my periods.
Um…. I hope you read up about such things before relying on them?
I was eating a soy food bar each day, as well, but stopped that recently as I’m also trying to eliminate foods to see if anything is also aggravating asthma.
Note that some of the advertised benefits of soy may be just wishful thinking, possibly based on a linguistic quibble. But do try eliminating foods–that was my first breakthrough in controlling my asthma.
Has anyone else experienced these problems? There are times my asthma flares and I cannot think of any reason other than major hormonal shifts in my body due just to menopause, never mind the HRT.
Sounds plausible.
My asthma doc says he knows that hormones can play a part in asthma but my OB/GYN has never heard of this.
Oh dear. I believe it’s even documented, so you don’t have to rely on anecdotes.
Sometimes feel like I’m losing my mind with all this going on…..
Know what you mean. Hang in there–there is an answer somewhere. ________________________________________________________________________ Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com) If you want a reply by e-mail, write to my GOL address!
Response:
I had a new bout with ashma at the onset of my peri. I also had bad allergies at puberty. With the help of my allergist and taking allergy shots, I’ve got it completely under control. No longer on pumps and meds, just the shots. It was worth the cost and inconvenience to take the treatments. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -On Mon, 13 Aug 2001 04:18:54 GMT, "Lynn" <hlang…@home.com
wrote: Hi, this is my first posting to this group. I was steered to this group by some very nice folks on the alt.support.asthma group. I am 47. When I take HRT (low dose BC pills, FemHrt or Estratest) I have full blown asthma attacks. (I’ve had night sweats, insomnia, can’t think straight, erratic periods or none at all and, for about the last year, no sex drive whatsoever!) Recently I’ve been really miserable and housebound from asthma. I’m off all the hormone pills, have been trying black cohosh and progesterone cream for 4 months now and it seems to have helped lessen the number of days I have the night sweats before my periods. I was eating a soy food bar each day, as well, but stopped that recently as I’m also trying to eliminate foods to see if anything is also aggravating asthma. Once I get through this attack, my OB/GYN wants me to try topical USP progesterone cream applied topically for low libido. I’m worried about trying it, though. Has anyone else experienced these problems? There are times my asthma flares and I cannot think of any reason other than major hormonal shifts in my body due just to menopause, never mind the HRT. My asthma doc says he knows that hormones can play a part in asthma but my OB/GYN has never heard of this. Thank heavens, he is a very nice, patient man and worked with me. Thanks for any help you can give. Sometimes feel like I’m losing my mind with all this going on….. Thanks for listening. Lynn
— Colette tr…@one.net
Response:
Thanks for the replies, I appreciate it! I went to my internist on Monday, had EKG, chest x-rays, oxygen level tests, etc. All is ok except for the asthma. It is finally starting to calm down some, I go back to see him next Monday and he is going to refer me to a pulmonist. He’s very gradually reducing the prednisone. I’ve been on allergy shots (again) for 4 years now and I really don’t see that they are helping. So, I’m going to ask my internist to refer me to a pulmonist that specializes in asthma and take it from there. I want off all the drugs eventually. I’m also starting beginners yoga next week (for the breathing for and stress of asthma, and menopause which, as a combination, does really suck!) and I’m having some massage and reflexology work done. I’ve stopped all herbs and progesterone cream and am starting from scratch when I get this all resolved. The only good thing about the last 2 weeks is that I have been too miserable with asthma to even notice the menopause stuff. Amazing what a gal will do to get away from the night sweats, hot flashes,etc…. huh? ;) Lynn "Louise Bremner" <dame_zum…@yahoo.com
wrote in message
news:1ey3yhw.1duzfxs1t7yj91N%dame_zumari@yahoo.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -
Lynn <hlang…@home.com wrote: Hi, this is my first posting to this group. Welcome to the group and to the fun process of peri…. No doubt someone with more specific info will be along in a minute (or maybe even before my message appears) to help you, but I’ll do for starters. Or p’raps you could start delving into the Land o’Links: <http://menopause.tripod.com for yourself. I am 47. When I take HRT (low dose BC pills, FemHrt or Estratest) I
have
full blown asthma attacks. Hmmmmm…. I found that going onto the Pill all those years ago actually improved my asthma (because whenever I was even a day later than the regulation 28 days, I’d start having horrendous cramps which seemed to trigger an attack, or maybe it was the hormone surge, or maybe it was just my bad mood, or maybe…). But when I was reading a.s.a, I got the impression from other people’s stories that any change in hormones in any direction can cause a change in asthma in any direction, so I could well believe that someone else can have problems. I wonder if you’re actually allergic to those versions of the Pill? I don’t mean allergic to the active ingredients, but to the allegedly inert padders that are added to make the Pill large enough for you to pick up and swallow? After all, there are some asthmatics who report they have problems with the new environmentally-friendly propellents used in inhalers. You could try asking your doctor to check what else is in those Pills, if you really want to continue trying them (I did my homework and decided to stop, but your situation seems different from mine–my asthma has improved recently). (I’ve had night sweats, insomnia, can’t think straight, erratic periods or none at all and, for about the last year, no sex drive whatsoever!) Yup. Sounds like you’ve come to the right place! (I’m experiencing a new variation at the moment–insomnia combined with jet-lag. This is not recommendable. Note that the rambling nature of this message can be blamed on the fact that it’s 2:40 AM and I did not manage to sleep significantly last night, but I’m still wide-awake. Drat it.) Recently I’ve been really miserable and housebound from asthma. How dismal. I’m off all the hormone pills, have been trying black cohosh and progesterone cream for 4 months now and it seems to have helped lessen
the
number of days I have the night sweats before my periods. Um…. I hope you read up about such things before relying on them? I was eating a soy food bar each day, as well, but stopped that recently as I’m also
trying
to eliminate foods to see if anything is also aggravating asthma. Note that some of the advertised benefits of soy may be just wishful thinking, possibly based on a linguistic quibble. But do try eliminating foods–that was my first breakthrough in controlling my asthma. Has anyone else experienced these problems? There are times my asthma flares and I cannot think of any reason other than major hormonal shifts
in
my body due just to menopause, never mind the HRT. Sounds plausible. My asthma doc says he knows that hormones can play a part in asthma but my OB/GYN has never
heard
of this. Oh dear. I believe it’s even documented, so you don’t have to rely on anecdotes. Sometimes feel like I’m losing my mind with all this going on….. Know what you mean. Hang in there–there is an answer somewhere. ________________________________________________________________________ Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com) If you want a reply by e-mail, write to my GOL address!
Response:
Pat Brimhall <pb…@ticnet.com
wrote: A lurker drops down from the rafters …
Welcome. (Um…. Since you use the "rafters" analogy, does that mean you’ve come from a certain other alt. group? Your name does look familiar.)
My mom found an even harsher "cure" for peri — chemotherapy.
My mother said it was the only diet that ever worked for her.
She says it was almost worth getting cancer for — but admittedly that’s easier to say now that she is almost 30 years cancer free.
I’m glad she recovered.
I must admit it is not a "cure" I am willing to try myself.
Agreed. I think there’d definitely be problems selling that one, too. ________________________________________________________________________ Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com) If you want a reply by e-mail, write to my GOL address!
Response:
Lynn <hlang…@home.com
wrote: The only good thing about the last 2 weeks is that I have been too miserable with asthma to even notice the menopause stuff. Amazing what a gal will do to get away from the night sweats, hot flashes,etc….
Sorry, no, I don’t think you’ve discovered the ideal solution to the problems raised by menopause–just imagine the problems of trying to sell this "cure". Keep trying!
huh?
Indeed. ________________________________________________________________________ Louise Bremner (log at gol dot com) If you want a reply by e-mail, write to my GOL address!
Response:
On Thu, 16 Aug 2001 18:30:50 +0900, dame_zum…@yahoo.com (Louise Bremner) wrote:
Lynn <hlang…@home.com wrote: The only good thing about the last 2 weeks is that I have been too miserable with asthma to even notice the menopause stuff. Amazing what a gal will do to get away from the night sweats, hot flashes,etc…. Sorry, no, I don’t think you’ve discovered the ideal solution to the problems raised by menopause–just imagine the problems of trying to sell this "cure". Keep trying! huh? Indeed.
A lurker drops down from the rafters to add — My mom found an even harsher "cure" for peri — chemotherapy. She was apparently starting peri when she got lymphoma (periods that lasted for two weeks and started again a week or two later, insomnia, irritablity). She had just started a period when the chemo started — that one stopped two days later and she never got another one. There were *no* other symptoms after that (or at least none distinguishable from the misery of chemo) Of course the chemo was pretty bad, but that lasted only 6 months. She says it was almost worth getting cancer for — but admittedly that’s easier to say now that she is almost 30 years cancer free. I must admit it is not a "cure" I am willing to try myself. Pat B — "If cats and humans live together, *someone* is going to get trained. Left to chance, it isn’t going to be the cat."
Response: